The Hard Truth About Adoption (Part 2)



In this series, I will explore some of the truths about adoption that I have discovered as an adoptee and now an adoptive mother of two girls. I recognize that every adoption experience is unique, and this is just an attempt to share my experiences. If you missed part 1 of this series, you can find it here.

Birth Family Relationships can be Complicated

I am very thankful to have a good relationship with one of my daughters’ birth families. We have lost touch with the other one’s family and it absolutely breaks my heart.

Even when everyone is agreeable and gets along, the birth family/adoptive family relationship can get complicated. As an adoptive mother, I have worried that one of my children would decide that they really preferred their other mother over me. I have worried about our birth families judging the way that we parent. I have tried to put on a “perfect” face for them just to prove to them that we really do love their daughters. But of course the truth is that, like any other family, we are flawed at best and really screwed up at worst.

It is important to have boundaries with the birth family, but it is also important that they know that they are loved and welcome. The birth family truly becomes part of your family.

I have made many mistakes with our birth families that I deeply regret. The truth is that when we adopted our oldest I was in my very early 20’s and now parenting an 8 year old. I wish that someone would have given me advice on forming a relationship with her mom, but no one did. Though it is challenging, it is worth it.

Open Adoption is Almost Always the Better Choice

The one situation that I would say closed adoption may be best is if there has been severe abuse at the hands of the birth family. If your child is not safe with them, then of course what kind of relationship you can safely have is going to be challenging.

I was adopted as an infant in a private, closed adoption. Thankfully, I have always felt 100 percent like I was a member of my family and have not had any major identity issues; however, I do wish that open adoption had been the norm in the 80’s. I spent many, many hours as a child dreaming of who my birth mother could be (and always somehow decided that it must be Amy Grant).

Closed adoption creates secrecy where there doesn’t need to be any. As adoptive parents, we need to be open and proud of where our children have come from. We need to affirm their history and answer the questions that they have about their identity. The best way to do this is to maintain some kind of relationship with the birth family. Although it may be challenging, it is almost always best.

The Emptiness of Infertility May Stick Around

When a couple has struggled with infertility for any length of time, a deep and painful wound can be created. And although adoption can be a beautiful way to create a family, it is not necessarily a “cure” for the pain that infertility causes.

I highly recommend that any couple who has struggled with infertility seek counseling before pursuing any kind of adoption. The pain that has been caused by infertility needs to be addressed and dealt with before welcoming an adoptive child into the family.

An adoptive child is not a “replacement” for a biological child and should not be viewed as such. They are not a “second choice.” Again, adoption is a wonderful way to create a family, but the wounds of infertility need to be dealt with first.

I’d love to hear from you! Please share your thoughts in the comments below.



4 thoughts on “The Hard Truth About Adoption (Part 2)

  1. Laughing about Amy Grant. I was really into her in the 80s, too.

    Yes, this: “We need to affirm their history and answer the questions that they have about their identity.”

    Thanks for visiting my blog today and leaving your comment.

  2. I feel as though our adoption was just the way I became a mother. The adoption doesn’t take anything away from how my son is my son and I am his mother. My infertility means nothing to me now 6 years later – just as a mom that gives birth via c-section. I’m blessed to have the son I have no matter how he came into my life. My infertility was a blessing! It lead me to my son.

    • I hope that this was not hurtful in any way. I did not mean it to be. I was adopted into my family after my parents had long struggled with infertility and I never felt second best. My husband and I have had fertility issues since the birth of our son also and have loved and welcomed a daughter into our family since then, who is just as precious and wonderful as my bio son. But I do know that for me, the longing to have another biological child is still there and I don’t foresee it disappearing. I have other friends who have adopted after infertility who still struggle with that desire as well. We are all on different journeys!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s